• •    

采伐对温带森林多尺度碳储量稳定性的影响及其多样性驱动机制

田源成, 张大明, 程岩, 何怀江, 张忠辉, 程艳霞, 张春雨   

  1. 北京林业大学, 北京 100083 中国
    吉林省林业实验区国有林保护中心, 132500
    吉林省林业科学研究院, 130022
  • 收稿日期:2026-05-21 修回日期:2026-06-25
  • 基金资助:
    国家重点研发计划资助(2023YFF1304003-05)

Effects of thinning on the multi-scale stability of carbon storage and its biodiversity-driven mechanisms in a temperate forest

TIAN Yuan-Cheng, ZHANG Da-Ming, CHENG Yan, HE Huai-Jiang, ZHANG Zhong-Hui, CHENG Yan-Xia, ZHANG Chun-Yu   

  1. , 100083, China
    , 132500,
    , 130022,
  • Received:2026-05-21 Revised:2026-06-25
  • Supported by:
    the National Key R&D Program of China(2023YFF1304003-05)

摘要: 经营性采伐是调控森林结构和维持生态系统功能的重要经营手段,但其对森林碳储量长期稳定性的跨尺度影响及其驱动路径仍不清晰。本研究基于温带针阔混交林2011-2025年的连续监测数据,将森林地上碳储量稳定性分解为局域(α)稳定性、空间异步性和较大尺度(γ)稳定性,结合线性混合效应模型和结构方程模型,分析了不同采伐强度下稳定性的变化。同时,从物种稳定性、物种异步性以及分类、功能和系统发育多样性等方面解析了影响碳储量稳定性的潜在生物学机制,结果表明:(1)采伐总体上降低了α和γ稳定性,这种负效应主要与物种稳定性的下降相关,而与物种异步性的关系相对较弱;(2)多样性与稳定性的关系在恢复阶段存在差异,第一恢复阶段主要与分类多样性相关,第二阶段更多体现为功能多样性的作用;(3)β功能多样性与空间异步性在第二恢复阶段呈负相关,表明功能组成变化可能削弱γ尺度的补偿效应;(4)尽管14年后各采伐样地的稳定性和物种丰富度均有所恢复,但重度采伐处理仍表现出较低的γ稳定性、物种稳定性和功能同质化趋势。研究表明,采伐对森林碳储量稳定性的影响具有明显的尺度依赖性和阶段差异,即使经历长期恢复,多样性与稳定性也未必能够同步恢复。

关键词: 经营性采伐;碳储量稳定性;时间稳定性;物种稳定性;空间异步性;物种多样性;森林恢复

Abstract: Management thinning is an important forest management practice for regulating forest structure and maintaining ecosystem functioning, yet its cross-scale effects on the long-term stability of forest carbon storage and the underlying pathways remain unclear.Based on continuous monitoring data from a temperate coniferous–broadleaved mixed forest from 2011 to 2025, this study decomposed the stability of aboveground forest carbon storage into local (α) stability, spatial asynchrony, and larger-scale (γ) stability. Linear mixed-effects models and structural equation models were then used to examine how stability changed under different thinning intensities. We further examined potential biological mechanisms underlying carbon-storage stability by considering species stability, species asynchrony, and taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic diversity.The results showed that:(1) thinning generally reduced both α and γ stability, and this negative effect was mainly associated with a decline in species stability, whereas its relationship with species asynchrony was relatively weak; (2) The relationship between diversity and stability varies across recovery stages: the first stage of recovery is primarily associated with taxonomic diversity, whereas the second stage is characterized more by the role of functional diversity; (3) β functional diversity was negatively related to spatial asynchrony in the later recovery stage, suggesting that changes in functional composition may weaken compensatory effects at the γ scale; and (4) although stability and species richness recovered to some extent in all thinned plots after 14 years, heavily thinned plots still showed lower γ stability, lower species stability, and a tendency toward functional homogenization. These findings indicate that the effects of thinning on the stability of forest carbon storage are clearly scale-dependent and stage-specific, and that even after long-term recovery, biodiversity and stability may not recover in parallel.

Key words: management thinning, carbon storage stability, temporal stability, species stability, spatial asynchrony, species diversity, forest recovery