• •    

大兴安岭落叶松与樟子松对气候响应的空间分异特征

吴家熙, 李祥友, 张冬有, 王兆鹏, 罗陶然, 谢远焕, 宋可心, 张雨硕, 姜远先, 芦琛, 韩国周   

  1. 哈尔滨师范大学地理科学学院, 黑龙江 150025 中国
    黑龙江乌伊岭湿地生态系统国家定位观测研究站, 153000
    乌伊岭湿地生态系统黑龙江省野外科学观测研究站, 153000
    内蒙古自治区呼伦贝尔市柴河自然保护区, 162650
    内蒙古自治区呼伦贝尔市根河市阿龙山森工公司, 022350
    内蒙古自治区呼伦贝尔市根河市阿龙山森工公司森林经营中心, 022350
  • 收稿日期:2026-03-18 修回日期:2026-08-06
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金(42571137)

Spatial Divergent Climate‑Response Characteristics of Larix gmelinii and Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica in the Greater Khingan Mountains.

  1. , 150025, China
    , 153000,
    , 162650,
    , 022350,
  • Received:2026-03-18 Revised:2026-08-06
  • Supported by:
    Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China.(42571137)

摘要: 【目的】探究大兴安岭兴安落叶松和樟子松在种间(相同经纬度)和种内(同经度不同纬度)尺度上对气候因子的差异化响应规律,揭示气候变暖背景下树木径向生长主导限制因子的转变机制及其对碳汇管理的启示。【方法】采集阿龙山林场落叶松(Larix gmelinii, 以下简称ALS)、柴河国家自然保护区落叶松(Larix gmelinii, 以下简称CHL)以及红花尔基巴日图林场樟子松(Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica, 以下简称BRT)样芯共159根,基于树木年代学构建树轮宽度标准年表。【结果】(1)种间尺度:CHL对春季(3月)最高温和最低温的响应分别呈极显著和显著负相关,而BRT呈显著正相关,表明二者采取相反的响应策略;(2)种内尺度:ALS对春季(2~4月)温度呈显著正相关,CHL则呈显著负相关,揭示纬度位置不同导致的主导限制因子发生分异。(3)1988年升温突变后,ALS树木年轮指数增大116.8 %,生长趋势由极显著下降变为不显著下降,BRT的树木年轮指数增大19.1 %,生长趋势由极显著下降变为极显著上升,而CHL的树木年轮指数和生长趋势均保持相对平稳。上年11月降水促进BRT生长,当年4月降水促进ALS生长。(4)滑动相关分析表明:ALS和BRT对温度的响应敏感性逐渐减弱,CHL对气候因子的响应敏感性逐渐增强。【结论】种间差异源于落叶松的“避险保守型”策略与樟子松的“机会利用型”策略的根本不同。基于北部(ALS)和南部(CHL)两个落叶松样点的对比,初步证据表明种内差异可能存在纬度位置不同导致的主导限制因子从“温度限制”向“水分限制”转变的潜在趋势,但该趋势尚需要更多中间纬度样点的验证。气候变暖正重塑大兴安岭森林格局:冻土区落叶松出现短期“变暖促生”现象,而樟子松因较强适应性可能在未来竞争中占据优势,扩大樟子松分布有助于维持区域碳汇长期稳定性。本研究为大兴安岭寒温带森林应对气候变化的碳汇管理提供了科学依据。

关键词: 树轮宽度, 气温突变, 种间, 种内, 响应差异

Abstract: Aims This study investigated the differential climatic responses of Larix gmelinii (Xing'an larch) and Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica (Mongolian pine) in the Greater Khingan Range at two spatial scales—interspecific (same longitude and latitude) and intraspecific (same longitude, different latitudes)—with the aim of elucidating the shifts in dominant limiting factors of radial growth under climate warming and their implications for carbon sink management. Methods A total of 159 tree cores were collected from Larix gmelinii at the Alongshan Forest Farm (ALS), Larix gmelinii at the Chaihe National Nature Reserve (CHL), and Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica at the Honghua'erjibartu Forest Farm (BRT). Tree-ring width standard chronologies were developed using dendrochronological methods. Findings (1) At the interspecific level, CHL exhibited a highly significant negative correlation with March maximum temperature and a significant negative correlation with March minimum temperature, while BRT showed a significant positive correlation, indicating opposite response strategies between the two species. (2) At the intraspecific level, ALS displayed a significant positive correlation with spring (February–April) temperatures, whereas CHL showed a significant negative correlation, suggesting a divergence in dominant limiting factors associated with latitudinal position. (3) Following an abrupt warming event in 1988, the tree-ring index of ALS increased by 116.8%, shifting from a highly significant decline to a non-significant decline; the index of BRT increased by 19.1%, shifting from a highly significant decline to a highly significant increase; while both the index and growth trend of CHL remained relatively stable. Precipitation in the previous November promoted growth at BRT, whereas precipitation in April of the current year promoted growth at ALS. (4) Moving correlation analysis revealed that the sensitivity of radial growth to temperature gradually decreased for ALS and BRT, while the sensitivity of CHL to climatic factors gradually increased. Conclusion The interspecific differences stem from the fundamental contrast between the "risk-averse, conservative" strategy of larch and the "opportunistic" strategy of Mongolian pine. Based on a comparison of two larch sites—one northern (ALS) and one southern (CHL)—preliminary evidence suggests that intraspecific differences may reflect a potential shift in dominant limiting factors from temperature limitation to water limitation associated with latitudinal position; however, this trend requires further validation with additional sites at intermediate latitudes. Climate warming is reshaping the forest dynamics of the Greater Khingan Range: larch in permafrost zones exhibits a short-term "warming-induced growth enhancement," while Mongolian pine, with its greater adaptability, may gain a competitive advantage in the future, potentially contributing to the long-term stability of the regional carbon sink. This study provides a scientific basis for adaptive forest management and carbon sink strategies in cold-temperate forests under climate change.

Key words: Tree ring width, abrupt temperature change, interspecific, intraspecific, response variation