Advances and prospects in plant symmetric and asymmetric competition

doi:10.17521/cjpe.2015.0051

Abstract

Abstract:

Competition among plant individuals is a critical process within a population and community and has long been a research focus in ecology, with particular attention on aboveground competition during growing seasons. The belowground competition of plant roots is equally-important, especially under water and nutrition stresses. Yet, our theoretical foundations for understanding the similarities and differences on belowground vs. aboveground completions remain immature. In this paper, we review up-to-date concepts and the understanding of aboveground and belowground competitions, summarize the relevant theories and associated conceptual frameworks, and present ways for testing these models for symmetric/asymmetric competitions. Additionally, we discussed the major variables involved in these processes and models. Finally, we shared our views on modeling competition for advancing ecological research in the future.

Key words: competition, concept, asymmetric, symmetric, environmental stress

CHEN Ren-Fei,JI Ming-Fei,GUAN Jia-Wei,DENG Jian-Ming. Advances and prospects in plant symmetric and asymmetric competition[J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 2015, 39(5): 530-540.

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://www.plant-ecology.com/EN/10.17521/cjpe.2015.0051

https://www.plant-ecology.com/EN/Y2015/V39/I5/530

References 64

1	Ballaré CL, Scopel AL (1997). Phytochrome signalling in plant canopies: Testing its population-level implications with photoreceptor mutants of Arabidopsis.Functional Ecology, 11, 441-450.
2	Ballaré CL, Scopel AL, Jordan ET, Vierstra RD (1994). Signaling among neighboring plants and the development of size inequalities in plant populations.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 91, 10094-10098.
3	Belfrage K, Björklund J, Salomonsson L (2015). Effects of farm size and on-farm landscape heterogeneity on biodiversity-case study of twelve farms in a Swedish landscape.Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems, 39, 170-188.
4	Bolte A, Villanueva I (2006). Interspecific competition impacts on the morphology and distribution of fine roots in European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) and Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.).European Journal of Forest Research, 125, 15-26.
5	Borer ET, Seabloom EW, Gruner DS, Harpole WS, Hillebrand H, Lind EM, Adler PB, Alberti J, Anderson TM, Bakker JD, Biederman L, Blumenthal D, Brown CS, Brudvig LA, Buckley YM, Cadotte M, Chu CJ, Cleland EE, Crawley MJ, Daleo P, Damschen EI, Davies KF, DeCrappeo NM, Du GZ, Firn J, Hautier Y, Heckman RW, Hector A, Iribarne O, Klein JA, Knops JMH, Pierre KJL, Leakey ADB, Li W, MacDougall AS, McCulley RL, Melbourne BA, Mitchell CE, Moore JL, Mortensen B, O’Halloran LR, Orrock JL, Pascual J, Prober SM, Pyke DA, Risch AC, Schuetz M, Smith MD, Stevens CJ, Sullivan LL, Williams RJ, Wragg PD, Wright JP, Yang LH (2014). Herbivores and nutrients control grassland plant diversity via light limitation.Nature, 508, 517-520.
6	Burns JH, Brandt AJ (2014). Heterogeneity in plant-soil feedbacks and resident population dynamics affect mutual invasibility.Journal of Ecology, 102, 1048-1057.
7	Casper BB, Jackson RB (1997). Plant competition underground.Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 28, 545-570.
8	Castro-Díez P, Godoy O, Alonso A, Gallardo A, Saldana A (2014). What explains variation in the impacts of exotic plant invasions on the nitrogen cycle? A meta-analysis.Ecology Letters, 17, 1-12.
9	Chu CJ, Maestre FT, Xiao S, Weiner J, Wang YS, Zheng HD, Wang G (2008). Balance between facilitation and resource competition determines biomass-density relationships in plant populations.Ecology Letters, 11, 1189-1197.
10	Chu CJ, Wang YS, Li Q, Zhao LQ, Ren ZW, Xiao S, Yuan JL, Wang G (2009). Effects of traits, species identity and local environmental conditions on the assessment of interactions: Insights from an alpine meadow community.Journal of Plant Ecology, 23, 135-141.
11	Chu CJ, Weiner J, Maestre FT, Wang YS, Morris C, Xiao S, Yuan JL, Du GZ, Wang G (2010). Effects of positive interactions, size symmetry of competition and abiotic stress on self-thinning in simulated plant populations.Annals of Botany, 106, 647-652.
12	Connoily J, Wayne P (1996). Asymmetric competition between plant species.Oecologia, 108, 311-320.
13	Craine JM, Fargione J, Sugita S (2005). Supply pre-emption, not concentration reduction, is the mechanism of competition for nutrients.New Phytologist, 166, 933-940.
14	de Kroon H, Mommer L, Nishiwaki A (2003). Root competition: Towards a mechanistic understanding.Root Ecology, 168, 215-234.
15	Deng JM, Wang GX, Morris EC, Wei XP, Li DX, Chen BM, Zhao CM, Liu J, Wang Y (2006). Plant mass-density relationship along a moisture gradient in north-west China.Journal of Ecology, 94, 953-958.
16	Deng JM, Ran JZ, Wang ZQ, Fan ZX, Wang GX, Ji MF, Liu J, Wang Y, Liu JQ, Brown JH (2012a). Models and tests of optimal density and maximal yield for crop plants.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,109, 15823-15828.
17	Deng JM, Zuo WY, Wang ZQ, Fan ZX, Ji MF, Wang GX, Ran JZ, Zhao CM, Liu JQ, Niklas KJ, Hammond ST, Brown JH (2012b). Insights into plant size-density relationships from models and agricultural crops.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,109, 8600-8605.
18	Facelli E, Facelli JM (2002). Soil phosphorus heterogeneity and mycorrhizal symbiosis regulate plant intra-specific competition and size distribution.Oecologia, 133, 54-61.
19	Falik O, Reides P, Gersani M, Novoplansky A (2003). Self/non-self discrimination in roots.Journal of Ecology, 91, 525-531.
20	Falik O, Reides P, Gersani M, Novoplansky A (2005). Root navigation by self inhibition.Plant, Cell & Environment, 28, 562-569.
21	Fargione J, Tilman D (2006). Plant species traits and capacity for resource reduction predict yield and abundance under competition in nitrogen-limited grassland.Functional Ecology, 20, 533-540.
22	Firbank LG, Watkinson AR (1985a). A model of interference within plant monocultures.Journal of Theoretical Biology, 116, 291-311.
23	Firbank LG, Watkinson AR (1985b). On the analysis of competition within two-species mixtures of plants.Journal of Applied Ecology, 22, 503-517.
24	Firbank LG, Watkinson AR (1987). On the analysis of competition at the level of the individual plant.Oecologia, 71, 308-317.
25	Freckleton RP, Watkinson AR (2001). Asymmetric competition between plant species.Functional Ecology, 15, 615-623.
26	Grace JB (1995). On the measurement of plant competition intensity.Ecology, 76, 305-308.
27	Gruntman M, Novoplansky A (2004). Physiologically mediated self/non-self discrimination in roots.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 101, 3863-3867.
28	Hautier Y, Niklaus PA, Hector A (2009). Competition for light causes plant biodiversity loss after eutrophication.Science, 324, 636-638.
29	Hautier Y, Seabloom EW, Borer ET, Adler PB, Harpole WS, Hillebrand H, Lind EM, MacDougall AS, Stevens CJ, Bakker JD, Buckley YM, Chu CJ, Collins SL, Daleo P, Damschen EI, Davies KF, Fay PA, Firn J, Gruner DS, Jin VL, Klein JA, Knops JMH, La Pierre KJ, Li W, McCulley RL, Melbourne BA, Moore JL, O’Halloran LR, Prober SM, Risch AC, Sankaran M, Schuetz M, Hector A (2014). Eutrophication weakens stabilizing effects of diversity in natural grasslands.Nature, 508, 521-525.
30	Holzapfel C, Alpert P (2003). Root cooperation in a clonal plant: Connected strawberries segregate roots.Oecologia, 134, 72-77.
31	Iponga DM, Milton SJ, Richardson DM (2008). Superiority in competition for light: A crucial attribute defining the impact of the invasive alien tree Schinus molle (Anacardiaceae) in South African Savanna.Journal of Arid Environments, 72, 612-623.
32	Kiær LP, Weisbach AN, Weiner J (2013). Root and shoot competition: A meta-analysis.Journal of Ecology, 101, 1298-1312.
33	Lei PF, Scherer-Lorenzen M, Bauhus J (2012). Belowground facilitation and competition in young tree species mixtures.Forest Ecology and Management, 265, 191-200.
34	Lin Y, Berger U, Grimm V, Ji QR (2012). Differences between symmetric and asymmetric facilitation matter: Exploring the interplay between modes of positive and negative plant interactions.Journal of Ecology, 100, 1482-1491.
35	Mahall BE, Callaway RM (1996). Effects of regional origin and genotype on intraspecific root communication in the desert shrub Ambrosia dumosa (Asteraceae).American Journal of Botany, 83, 93-98.
36	Mariotte P, Buttler A, Johnson D, Thébault A, Vandenberghe C (2012). Exclusion of root competition increases competitive abilities of subordinate plant species through root-shoot interactions.Journal of Vegetation Science, 23, 1148-1158.
37	Osunkoya OO, Perrett C, Fernando C, Clark C (2013). Patterns of seed bank and size asymmetry of plant growth across varying sites in the invasive Lantana camara L. (Verbenaceae).Plant Ecology, 214, 725-736.
38	Rajaniemi TK (2003). Evidence for size asymmetry of belowground competition.Basic and Applied Ecology, 4, 239-247.
39	Rajaniemi TK (2011). Competition for patchy soil resources reduces community evenness.Oecologia, 165, 169-174.
40	Rajaniemi TK, Allison VJ, Goldberg DE (2003). Root competition can cause a decline in diversity with increased productivity.Journal of Ecology, 91, 407-416.
41	Reubens B, Achten WMJ, Maes WH, Danjon F, Aerts R, Poesen J, Muys B (2011). More than biofuel? Jatropha curcas root system symmetry and potential for soil erosion control.Journal of Arid Environments, 75, 201-205.
42	Rewald B, Leuschner C (2009). Does root competition asymmetry increase with water availability?Plant Ecology & Diversity, 2, 255-264.
43	Sapijanskas J, Paquette A, Potvin C, Kunert N, Loreau M (2014). Tropical tree diversity enhances light capture through crown plasticity and spatial and temporal niche differences.Ecology, 95, 2479-2492.
44	Schenk JH (2006). Root competition: Beyond resource depletion.Journal of Ecology, 94, 725-739.
45	Schwinning S, Fox GA (1995). Population dynamic consequences of competitive symmetry in annual plants.Oikos, 72, 422-432.
46	Schwinning S, Weiner J (1998). Mechanisms determining the degree of size asymmetry in competition among plants.Oecologia, 113, 447-455.
47	Skácelová O, Lepš J (2014). The relationship of diversity and biomass in phytoplankton communities weakens when accounting for species proportions.Hydrobiologia, 724, 67-77.
48	Šmilauer P, Šmilauerová M (2013). Asymmetric relationship between grasses and forbs: Results from a field experiment under nutrient limitation.Grass and Forage Science, 68, 186-198.
49	Sutherland WJ, Freckleton RP, Godfray HCJ, Beissinger SR, Benton T, Cameron DD, Carmel Y, Coomes DA, Coulson T, Emmerson MC, Hails RS, Hays GC, Hodgson DJ, Hutchings MJ, Johnson D, Jones JPG, Keeling MJ, Kokko H, Kunin WE, Lambin X, Lewis OT, Malhi Y, Mieszkowska N, Milner-Gulland EJ, Norris K, Phillimore AB, Purves DW, Reid JM, Reuman DC, Thompson K, Travis JMJ, Turnbull LA, Wardle DA, Wiegand T (2013). Identification of 100 fundamental ecological questions.Journal of Ecology, 101, 58-67.
50	Thomas EM, Weiner J (1989). Local density variation may mimic effects of asymmetric competition on plant size variability.Ecology, 70, 1188-1191.
51	van Leeuwen E, Etienne RS (2013). Caught in the middle: Asymmetric competition causes high variance in intermediate trait abundances.Theoretical Population Biology, 85, 26-37.
52	Wang G, Zhang DY (1996). Theory of Biology Competition. Shaanxi Science and Technology Press, Xi’an(in Chinese)
	[王刚, 张大勇 (1996). 生物竞争理论. 陕西科学技术出版社, 西安.]
53	Wang P, Wang TH, Zhou DW, Zhang HX (2007). A literature review on the above- and below-ground competition.Acta Ecologica Sinica, 27, 3489-3499.(in Chinese with English abstract)
	[王平, 王天慧, 周道玮, 张红香 (2007). 植物地上竞争与地下竞争研究进展. 生态学报, 27, 3489-3499.]
54	Warren RJ, Giladi I, Bradford MA (2014). Competition as a mechanism structuring mutualisms.Journal of Ecology, 102, 486-495.
55	Weiner J (1986). How competition for light and nutrients affects size variability in ipomoea tricolor populations.Ecology, 67, 1425-1427.
56	Weiner J, Wright DB, Castro S (1997). Symmetry of below- ground competition between Kochia scoparia individuals.Oikos, 79, 85-91.
57	Weiner J, Griepentrog HW, Kristensen L (2001). Suppression of weeds by spring wheat Triticum aestivum increases with crop density and spatial uniformity.Journal of Applied Ecology, 38, 784-790.
58	Weiner J, Thomas SC (1986). Size variability and competition in plant monocultures.Oikos, 47, 211-222.
59	Weremijewicz J, Janos DP (2013). Common mycorrhizal networks amplify size inequality in Andropogon gerardii monocultures.New Phytologist, 198, 203-213.
60	Wilensky U (. Cited: 2014-11-10.
61	Wolfe BE, Klironomos JN (2005). Breaking new ground: Soil communities and exotic plant invasion.BioScience, 55, 477-487.
62	Yang GW, Liu N, Lu WJ, Wang S, Kan HM, Zhang YJ, Xu L, Chen YL (2014). The interaction between arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and soil phosphorus availability influences plant community productivity and ecosystem stability.Journal of Ecology, 102, 1072-1082.
63	Zhang WP, Jia X, Damgaard C, Morris EC, Bai YY, Pan S, Wang GX (2013). The interplay between above- and below-ground plant-plant interactions along an environmental gradient: Insights from two-layer zone-of-influence models.Oikos, 122, 1147-1156.
64	Zhi YB, Li HL, An SQ, Zhao L, Zhou CF, Deng ZF (2007). Inter-specific competition: Spartina alterniflora is replacing Spartina anglica in coastal China.Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science, 74, 437-448.

[1]	建周 Han Wang. A review of forest size structure studies: from statistical description to theoretical deduction [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2024, 48(预发表): 0-0.
[2]	Bei DENG feng XiaoWANG. Meta-analysis analysis the effects of environmental stress on the physiological and ecological characteristics of herbaceous and woody plants in the hydro-fluctuation belt of the Three Gorges Reservoir area [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2024, 48(5): 623-637.
[3]	LI Wei-Bin, ZHANG Hong-Xia, ZHANG Yu-Shu, CHEN Ni-Na. Influence of diurnal asymmetric warming on carbon sink capacity in a broadleaf Korean pine forest in Changbai Mountains, China [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2023, 47(9): 1225-1233.
[4]	RAN Song-Song, YU Zai-Peng, WAN Xiao-Hua, FU Yan-Rong, ZOU Bing-Zhang, WANG Si-Rong, HUANG Zhi-Qun. Effects of neighborhood tree species diversity on foliar nitrogen-phosphorus stoichiometry of Cunninghamia lanceolata [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2023, 47(7): 932-942.
[5]	ZHANG Zeng-Ke, LI Zeng-Yan, YANG Bai-Yu, SAI Bi-Le, YANG An-Na, ZHANG Li, MOU Ling, ZHENG Jun-Yong, JIN Le-Wei, ZHAO Zhao, WANG Wan-Sheng, DU Yun-Cai, YAN En-Rong. Functional traits influence the growth and mortality of common woody plants in Dajinshan Island, Shanghai, China [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2023, 47(10): 1398-1406.
[6]	SHI Huan-Huan, XUE Qiong, YU Zhen-Lin, WANG Cheng-Huan. Effects of density and species proportion on intraspecific and interspecific interactions between salt marsh plants during seed germination [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2023, 47(1): 77-87.
[7]	ZHAO Chang-Xing, ZHAO Wei-Jun, ZHANG Xing-Lin, LIU Si-Min, MOU Wen-Bo, LIU Jin-Rong. Analyses of intraspecific competition and facilitation of Picea crassifolia in Pailugou Watershed of Qilian Mountains, China [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2022, 46(9): 1027-1037.
[8]	LIU Mu-Qing, YANG Xiao-Feng, SHI Yu-Ming, LIU Yu-Wei, LI Xiao-Meng, LIAO Wan-Jin. Effects of simulated acid rain on the competitive relationship between invasive Ambrosia artemisiifolia and its co-occurring indigenous forb Bidens bipinnata [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2022, 46(8): 932-940.
[9]	XIE Wei, HAO Zhi-Peng, ZHANG Xin, CHEN Bao-Dong. Research progress and prospect of signal transfer among plants mediated by arbuscular mycorrhizal networks [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2022, 46(5): 493-515.
[10]	HAN Cong, LIU Peng, MU Yan-Mei, YUAN Yuan, HAO Shao-Rong, TIAN Yun, ZHA Tian-Shan, JIA Xin. Response of ecosystem carbon balance to asymmetric daytime vs nighttime warming in Artemisia ordosica shrublands [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2022, 46(12): 1473-1485.
[11]	TAN Yi-Bo, TIAN Hong-Deng, ZENG Chun-Yang, SHEN Hao, SHEN Wen-Hui, YE Jian-Ping, GAN Guo-Juan. Canopy mechanical abrasion between adjacent plants influences twig and leaf traits of Tsuga chinensis assemblage in the Mao’er Mountain [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2021, 45(12): 1281-1291.
[12]	PANG Fang, XIA Wei-Kang, HE Min, QI Shan-Shan, DAI Zhi-Cong, DU Dao-Lin. Nitrogen-fixing bacteria alleviates competition between arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and Solidago canadensis for nutrients under nitrogen limitation [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2020, 44(7): 782-790.
[13]	KANG Jian, LIANG Han-Xue, JIANG Shao-Wei, ZHU Huo-Xing, ZHOU Peng, HUANG Jian-Guo. Effects of competition and climate on tree radial growth of Pinus sibirica in Altai Mountains, Xinjiang, China [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2020, 44(12): 1195-1202.
[14]	Dan WANG, Yun-Zhou QIAO, Bao-Di DONG, Jing GE, Ping-Guo YANG, Meng-Yu LIU. Differential effects of diurnal asymmetric and symmetric warming on yield and water utilization of soybean [J]. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2016, 40(8): 827-833.
[15]	Ming-Xiu LIU, Guo-Lu LIANG. Research progress on leaf mass per area [J]. Chin J Plan Ecolo, 2016, 40(8): 847-860.