东北地区芦苇植硅体的变化特征

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1258.2013.00090

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

深入研究芦苇(Phragmites australis)不同生长期植硅体的形态变化规律, 对提高古植被重建精度、探讨植硅体形成机理具有重要意义。该文对东北地区12个样点的芦苇叶片进行研究, 选取长势相近、叶片大小一致的芦苇叶片, 用湿式灰化法提取植硅体并对其进行分类和命名。研究发现, 芦苇植硅体主要有5种类型, 在不同生长期内和不同温湿度组合下, 其植硅体类型组合基本无变化, 说明同种植物的植硅体类型组合具有稳定性, 据此可以有效地恢复古植被; 同时芦苇鞍型植硅体百分含量的峰值出现在7月份, 随后稍有减少, 而芦苇扇型植硅体百分含量和浓度的峰值出现在8或9月份, 谷值在7月份。由此推测芦苇鞍型植硅体的形成可能更多地受控于植物的光合作用和蒸腾作用, 芦苇扇型植硅体的形成可能与机动细胞的支撑作用关系密切。实验结果还表明芦苇植硅体浓度并不是随着时间逐渐积累的, 其在8月份达到峰值, 9月份达到谷值, 因此推测植物植硅体浓度的变化规律可能与植物在不同生长期其自身对硅的需求规律相一致。鞍型植硅体浓度的峰值也出现在8月份, 谷值也在9月份, 其浓度变化与芦苇植硅体总浓度的变化趋势相似。

关键词: 变化特征, 生长期, 东北地区, 芦苇, 植硅体

Abstract:

Aims Our objective is to study the change rules of the main phytolith morphotypes in Phragmites australis from June to October.
Methods We selected similarly sized leaves of P. australis in 12 sampling sites and extracted phytoliths with the wet-ashing method.
Important findings The main phytolith morphotypes in P. australis could be classified into five categories. There is little change about the phytolith assemblages in P. australis during different growth periods and different combination of temperature and humidity. This implies that phytolith morphotypes of the same plant species are stable and therefore can be used to effectively reconstruct paleo-vegetation. The maximum value of the saddle percentage appears in July and then slightly decreases. While the maximum value of the percentage and concentration of the bulliform appears in August or September, with its minimum value in July. This indicates that the saddle formation may be more controlled by plant photosynthesis and transpiration, while the bulliform formation may be closely associated with the support of bulliform cells. The result also shows that the phytolith concentration in P. australis does not gradually accumulate from June to October. Its maximum value appears in August and its minimum value in September, so the change rules of the phytolith concentration may be concordant with the need of silicon for plants in different growth periods. Furthermore, the maximum value of the saddle concentration in P. australis also appears in August, with its minimum value in September. This trend is similar to changes of the phytolith concentration in P. australis.

Key words: change character, growth period, Northeast China, Phragmites australis, phytolith

刘利丹, 介冬梅, 刘洪妍, 郭梅娥, 李楠楠. 东北地区芦苇植硅体的变化特征. 植物生态学报, 2013, 37(9): 861-871. DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1258.2013.00090

LIU Li-Dan, JIE Dong-Mei, LIU Hong-Yan, GUO Mei-E, LI Nan-Nan. Change characters of Phragmites australis phytolith in Northeast China. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 2013, 37(9): 861-871. DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1258.2013.00090

导出引用管理器 EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

链接本文: https://www.plant-ecology.com/CN/10.3724/SP.J.1258.2013.00090

https://www.plant-ecology.com/CN/Y2013/V37/I9/861

图/表 9

参考文献 43

[1]	An XH, Lü HY (2010). Altitudinal distribution of phytolith assemblages in topsoil from the east slope of Gongga Mountain, Southeastern Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau and their relationship with vegetation composition. Quaternary Science, 30, 934-942. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[安晓红, 吕厚远 (2010). 贡嘎山东坡表土植硅体组合的海拔分布及其与植被的关系. 第四纪研究, 30, 934-942.]
[2]	Bian Y, Pan XL (1995). Observation of plant spit water phenomenon. Plants, (5),38. (in Chinese)
	[卞勇, 潘晓琳 (1995). 植物吐水现象的观察. 植物杂志, (5), 38.]
[3]	Chen LK, Guo JQ, Gu YS (2008a). Characteristics of phytolith assemblages from sediments of modern river floodplain and first terraces in Lhasa River, Tibet. Actased Mentologica Sinica, 26, 479-485. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[陈陵康, 郭建秋, 顾延生 (2008a). 西藏拉萨河现代河漫滩及一级阶地沉积物植硅体组合特征. 沉积学报, 26, 479-485.]
[4]	Chen LK, Guo JQ, Gu YS, Chen HX (2008b). Characteristics of phytolith assemblages of quaternary in Sangda region of Lhasa, Tibet. Scientia Geographia Sinica, 28, 402-406. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[陈陵康, 郭建秋, 顾延生, 陈海霞 (2008b). 西藏拉萨桑达地区第四纪植硅体组合特征. 地理科学, 28, 402-406.]
[5]	Fredlund GG, Tieszen LT (1997). Phytolith and carbon isotope evidence for late Quaternary vegetation and climate change in the southern Black Hills, South Dakota. Quaternary Research, 47, 206-217.
[6]	Ge Y, Jie DM, Guo JX, Liu HM, Shi LX (2010). Response of phytoliths in Leymus chinensis to the simulation of elevated global CO₂ concentrations in Songnen Grassland, China. Chinese Science Bulletin, 55, 2735-2741.. (in Chinese)
	[葛勇, 介冬梅, 郭继勋, 刘红梅, 石连旋 (2010). 松嫩草原羊草植硅体对模拟全球CO₂浓度升高的响应研究. 科学通报, 55, 2735-2741.]
[7]	Geng YX, Li YL, Zhu S, Zhu JJ, Jiang JC, Niu HH, Jie DM (2011). Morphological changes of phytoliths in Leymus chinensis under saline-alkali stress. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 35, 1148-1155. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[耿云霞, 李依玲, 朱莎, 朱精精, 姜俊丞, 牛洪昊, 介冬梅 (2011). 盐碱胁迫下羊草植硅体的形态变化. 植物生态学报, 35, 1148-1155.]
[8]	Guo TF (1994). Effects of silicon on the Oryza sativa during different stages. He’nan Science & Technology, (7),30-31. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[郭惕菲 (1994). 硅对水稻不同生育期的影响. 河南科技, (7),30-31.]
[9]	Hao XY, Han X, Li P, Yang HB, Lin ED (2011). Effects of elevated atmospheric CO₂concentration on mung bean leaf photosynthesis and chlorophyll fluorescence parameters. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 22, 2776-2780. (in Chinese with English abstract) URL PMID
	[郝兴宇, 韩雪, 李萍, 杨宏斌, 林而达 (2011). 大气CO₂浓度升高对绿豆叶片光合作用及叶绿素荧光参数的影响. 应用生态学报, 22, 2776-2780.] PMID
[10]	Huang F, Kealhofer L, Huang FB (2004a). Diagnostic phytoliths from Nei Mongol Grassland. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica, 43, 246-253. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[黄翡, Kealhofer L, 黄凤宝 (2004a). 内蒙古典型草原禾本科植硅体形态. 古生物学报, 43, 246-253.]
[11]	Huang F, Kealhofer L, Huang FB (2004b). Phytolith record of surface samples from central eastern Inner Mongolia and their relationship to the modern vegetation. Acta Micropalaeontologica Sinica, 21, 419-430. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[黄翡, Kealhofer L, 黄凤宝 (2004b). 内蒙古草原中东部现代表土植硅体组合与植被关系. 微体古生物学报, 21, 419-430.]
[12]	Jie DM, Ge Y, Guo JX, Liu HM (2010a). Response of phytolith in Leymus chinensis to the simulation of global warming and nitrogen deposition on Songnen grassland, China. Environmental Science, 31, 1708-1715. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[介冬梅, 葛勇, 郭继勋, 刘红梅 (2010a). 中国松嫩草原羊草植硅体对环球变暖和氮沉降模拟的响应研究. 环境科学, 31, 1708-1715.]
[13]	Jie DM, Liu ZY, Shi LX, Liu HM, Ge Y (2010b). Characteristics of phytoliths in Leymus chinensis from different habitats on the Songnen Plain in Northeast China and their environmental implications. Science in China, 40, 493-502. (in Chinese)
	[介冬梅, 刘朝阳, 石连旋, 刘红梅, 葛勇 (2010b). 松嫩平原不同生境羊草植硅体形态特征及环境意义. 中国科学, 40, 493-502.]
[14]	Jin GY, Yan DS, Uda TT, Lan YF, Wang CY, Tong PH (2007). Phytolith evidence of Shandong Jiaozhou Zhao- jiazhuang site 4000 years ago. Chinese Science Bulletin, 52, 2161-2168. (in Chinese)
	[靳桂云, 燕生东, 宇田津彻郎, 兰玉富, 王春燕, 佟佩华 (2007). 山东胶州赵家庄遗址4000年前稻田的植硅体证据. 科学通报, 52, 2161-2168.]
[15]	Kazuo N (1989). Effects of silicon on the growth and development of the Oryza sativa, Sou Su. Plant Nutrition, 35, 347-356.
[16]	Kondo R, Childs C, Atkinson I (1994). Opal phytoliths of New Zealand. Manaaki Whenua Press, Lincoln, New Zealand. 85.
[17]	Li Q, Xu DK, Lü HY (2005). Morphology of phytolith in Bambusoideae (Gramineae) and its ecological significance. Quaternary Science, 25, 777-784. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[李泉, 徐德克, 吕厚远 (2005). 竹亚科植硅体形态学研究及其生态学意义. 第四纪研究, 25, 777-784.]
[18]	Li XZ, Liu ZW, Sun L (2005). Change characteristics of pumpkin net photosynthetic rate and its ecological physiology factor with time. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences, 33, 1028-1029. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[李新峥, 刘振威, 孙丽 (2005). 南瓜净光合速率及其生理生态因子时间变化特征. 安徽农业科学, 33, 1028-1029.]
[19]	Li YY, Leng XT (1997). The comparative study of Pollen- Spora analysis and formation environment of peat mire between Northeast of China and Belarus. Journal of Northeast Normal University (Natural Science), (3),97-103. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[李宜垠, 冷雪天 (1997). 中国东北与白俄罗斯泥炭沼泽的孢粉分析与形成环境对比. 东北师范大学学报(自然科学版), (3),97-103.]
[20]	Lü HY, Ja JW, Wang WM, Wang YJ, Liao GB (2002). On the meaning of phytolith and its classification in Gramineae. Acta Micropalaeontologica Sinica, 19, 389-396. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[吕厚远, 贾继伟, 王伟铭, 王永吉, 廖淦标 (2002). “植硅体”含义和禾本科植硅体的分类. 微体古生物学报, 19, 389-396.]
[21]	Lü HY, Wu NQ, Liu DS, Han JM, Qin XG, Sun XJ, Wang YJ (1996). Seasonal climatic variation recorded by phytolith assemblages from the Baoji loess sequence in Central China over the last 150000 a. Science in China (Series D), 26, 123-136. (in Chinese)
	[吕厚远, 吴乃琴, 刘东生, 韩家懋, 秦小光, 孙湘君, 王永吉 (1996). 150ka来宝鸡黄土植物硅酸体组合季节性气候变化. 中国科学(D辑), 26, 123-136.]
[22]	Lü HY, Wu NQ, Liu KB, Jiang H, Liu TS (2007). Phytoliths as quantitative indicators for the reconstruction of past environmental conditions in China II: Palaeoenvironmental reconstruction in the Loess Plateau. Quaternary Science Reviews, 26, 759-772.
[23]	Lü HY, Wu NQ, Yang XD, Jiang H, Liu KB, Liu TS (2006). Phytoliths as quantitative indicators for the reconstruction of past environmental conditions in China I: Phytolith- based transfer functions. Quaternary Science Reviews, 25, 945-959.
[24]	Prat H (1932). L,epiderme des Graminees (The epidermis of Gramineae). Annales des Sciences Naturelles: Botanique, series 10, 14, 117-324.
[25]	Qin L, Li J, Wang L, Lü HY (2008). The morphology and assemblages of phytolish in Pooideae from the Qinghai Tibetan Plateau. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica, 47, 176-184. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[秦利, 李杰, 旺罗, 吕厚远 (2008). 青藏高原常见早熟禾亚科植硅体形态特征初步研究. 古生物学报, 47, 176-184.]
[26]	Schwarz AG, Redmann RE (1990). Phenology of northern populations of halophytic C3 and C4 grasses. Canadian Journal of Botany, 68, 1817-1821.
[27]	Sun XL, Ren BZ, Zhao Z, Gao CQ, Zhou GP (2006). Faunal composition of grasshopper in different habitats of Northeast China. Chinese Journal of Ecology, 25, 286-289. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[孙晓玲, 任炳忠, 赵卓, 高长启, 周广平 (2006). 东北地区不同生境内蝗虫区系的比较. 生态学杂志, 25, 286-289.]
[28]	Tong P, Yang SM, Ma J, Wu HZ, Fu TL, Li M, Wang MT (2008). Photosynthetic characteristics and dry matter accumulation of hybrid rice varieties under different light conditions. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 19, 505-511. (in Chinese with English abstract) URL PMID
	[童平, 杨世民, 马均, 吴合洲, 傅泰露, 李敏, 王明田 (2008). 不同水稻品种在不同光照条件下的光合特性及干物质积累. 应用生态学报, 19, 505-511.] PMID
[29]	Wang L (2006). Ecophysiology Adaptation of Dominant Grasses and Their Response to Simulated Climatic Changes in the Songnen Grassland of China. PhD dissertation, Northeast Normal University, Changchun. 51. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	王立 (2006). 松嫩草地优势禾草生理生态的适应特性及其对模拟气候变化的响应. 博士论文, 东北师范大学, 长春. 51.]
[30]	Wang M, Wang YB, Chen ZH (2010). Germplasm resource of Phragmites adans and its application in constructed wetland. Chinese Journal of Applied and Environmental Biology, 16, 590-595. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[王萌, 王玉彬, 陈章和 (2010). 芦苇的种质资源及在人工湿地中的应用. 应用与环境生物学报, 16, 590-595.]
[31]	Wang YJ, Lü HY (1992). The Study of Phytolith and Its Application. China Ocean Press, Beijing.1-228.
	[王永吉, 吕厚远 (1992). 植物硅酸体研究及应用. 海洋出版社, 北京.1-228.]
[32]	Wang YJ, Lü HY (1994). Methods of phytolith analysis. Acta Botanica Sinica, 36, 797-804. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[王永吉, 吕厚远 (1994). 植物硅酸体的分析方法. 植物学报, 36, 797-804.]
[33]	Wu NQ, Lü HY, Nie GZ, Wang YJ, Meng Y, Gu GA (1992). The study of phytolith in C₃and C₄ grasses and its paleoecological significance. Quaternary Science, 8, 241-251. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[吴乃琴, 吕厚远, 聂高众, 王永吉, 孟毅, 顾国安 (1992). C₃、C₄植物及其硅酸体研究的古生态意义. 第四纪研究, 8, 241-251.]
[34]	Wu NQ, Lü HY, Sun XJ, Guo ZT (1995). Climatic factor transfer function from opal phytolith and its application in paleoclimate reconstruction of China loess-paleosol sequence. Scientia Geologica Sinica, (Suppl. 1), 105-114.
[35]	Xiao QM, Ma XQ, Lou CR, Sun WT, Fu ZX (1999). The research to relationship between the stage nutrition of corn silicon and effective silicon of soil. Chinese Journal of Soil Science, 30, 185-188. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[肖千明, 马兴全, 娄春荣, 孙文涛, 付仲鑫 (1999). 玉米硅的阶段营养与土壤有效硅关系研究. 土壤通报, 30, 185-188.]
[36]	Xu DK, Li Q, Lü HY (2005). Morphological analysis of phytoliths in Palmae and its environmental significance. Quaternary Sciences, 25, 785-982. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[徐德克, 李泉, 吕厚远 (2005). 棕榈科植硅体形态分析及其环境意义. 第四纪研究, 25, 785-982.]
[37]	Xu K, Guo YP, Zhang SL, Zhou HF, Zheng Y (2005). Response of strawberry leaves photosynthesis to strong light and its mechanism. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 16, 73-78. (in Chinese with English abstract) URL PMID
	[徐凯, 郭延平, 张上隆, 周慧芬, 郑毅 (2005). 草莓叶片光合作用对强光的响应及其机理研究. 应用生态学报, 16, 73-78.] PMID
[38]	Yan JP, Wei YC (1985). Research to the law of summer corn guttation. Journal of Baiquan Agricultural College, 13(1),58-65. (in Chinese)
	[严竞平, 魏永超 (1985). 夏玉米吐水规律的研究. 百泉农专学报, 13(1),58-65.]
[39]	Zhang XR, Hu K, Wang DP, Jie DM (2004). Discussion on research and application of phytolith. Global Geology, 23, 112-115. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张新荣, 胡克, 王东坡, 介冬梅 (2004). 植硅体研究及其应用的讨论. 世界地质, 23, 112-115.]
[40]	Zhang YL, Zhang MB, Song J (2003). Observing ancestors farming development from phytolith assemblages characteristics of wide rich forest site. Chinese Science Bulletin, 48, 96-99. (in Chinese)
	[张玉兰, 张敏斌, 宋建 (2003). 从广富林遗址中的植硅体组合特征看先民农耕发展. 科学通报, 48, 96-99.]
[41]	Zhang YM, Yang YF, Wang LJ (2006). Studies on seasonal dynamics of production and allocation in Phragmites australis population in Sanjiang Wetland Plain. Chinese Journal of Grassland, 28, 1-5. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[张友民, 杨允菲, 王立军 (2006). 三江平原沼泽湿地芦苇种群生产与分配的季节动态. 中国草地学报, 28, 1-5.]
[42]	Zhao GS, Wang JB, Fan WY, Ying TY (2011). Vegetation net primary productivity in Northeast China in 2000-2008: simulation and seasonal change. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 22, 621-630. (in Chinese with English abstract) URL PMID
	[赵国帅, 王军邦, 范文义, 应天玉 (2011). 2000-2008年中国东北地区植被净初级生产力的模拟及季节变化. 应用生态学报, 22, 621-630.] PMID
[43]	Zhou Q, Pan GQ, Shi ZJ, Chen FH (2001). Effects of silicon on the yield and quality of Oryza sativa. Cultivation and Protection, 3, 25-27. (in Chinese with English abstract)
	[周青, 潘国庆, 施作家, 陈风华 (2001). 不同时期施用硅肥对水稻群体质量及产量的影响. 耕作与保护, 3, 25-27.]

地点 Site	经度 Longitude (E)	纬度 Latitude (N)	海拔 Altitude (m)	类型差异 Difference of types	含量差异 Difference of contents
丹东 Dandong	123°36′04.0″	39°52′18.8″	5	无 No	有 Yes
盘锦 Panjin	121°38′09.7″	40°54′26.4″	5	无 No	有 Yes
龙湾 Longwan	126°22′03.5″	42°21′027″	453	无 No	有 Yes
通辽 Tongliao	121°02′31.09″	43°20′45.4″	-	无 No	有 Yes
长春 Changchun	125°18′46.1″	43°50′49.7″	216	无 No	有 Yes
牡丹江 Mudanjiang	128°50′37″	44°04′49.4″	366	无 No	有 Yes
长岭 Changling	123°36.7′03.9″	44°36.5′0.6″	143	无 No	有 Yes
哈尔滨 Harbin	126°53′54.9″	45°54′10.7″	116	无 No	有 Yes
大庆 Daqing	125°10′55.8″	46°32′035″	-	无 No	有 Yes
同江 Tongjiang	133°35′10.3″	47°44′39.6″	47	无 No	有 Yes
北安 Beian	126°25′25.0″	48°23′14.6″	277	无 No	有 Yes
讷河 Nehe	124°52′43.9″	48°27′52.6″	194	无 No	有 Yes

地点 Site	经度 Longitude (E)	纬度 Latitude (N)	海拔 Altitude (m)	类型差异 Difference of types	含量差异 Difference of contents
丹东 Dandong	123°36′04.0″	39°52′18.8″	5	无 No	有 Yes
盘锦 Panjin	121°38′09.7″	40°54′26.4″	5	无 No	有 Yes
龙湾 Longwan	126°22′03.5″	42°21′027″	453	无 No	有 Yes
通辽 Tongliao	121°02′31.09″	43°20′45.4″	-	无 No	有 Yes
长春 Changchun	125°18′46.1″	43°50′49.7″	216	无 No	有 Yes
牡丹江 Mudanjiang	128°50′37″	44°04′49.4″	366	无 No	有 Yes
长岭 Changling	123°36.7′03.9″	44°36.5′0.6″	143	无 No	有 Yes
哈尔滨 Harbin	126°53′54.9″	45°54′10.7″	116	无 No	有 Yes
大庆 Daqing	125°10′55.8″	46°32′035″	-	无 No	有 Yes
同江 Tongjiang	133°35′10.3″	47°44′39.6″	47	无 No	有 Yes
北安 Beian	126°25′25.0″	48°23′14.6″	277	无 No	有 Yes
讷河 Nehe	124°52′43.9″	48°27′52.6″	194	无 No	有 Yes

样点 Site	鞍型 Saddle	帽型 Rondel	尖型 Lanceolate	扇型 Bulliform	棒型 Elongated
丹东 Dandong	78.95	7.66	0.89	7.17	5.33
盘锦 Panjin	79.20	9.04	3.71	2.75	5.30
龙湾 Longwan	87.33	6.00	1.02	4.18	1.47
通辽 Tongliao	88.31	7.80	0.53	0.98	2.38
长春 Changchun	83.90	5.60	2.19	5.60	2.71
牡丹江 Mudanjiang	84.58	4.24	1.19	8.07	1.92
长岭 Changling	85.06	6.58	3.71	2.60	2.05
哈尔滨 Harbin	53.22	3.20	18.02	17.29	8.27
大庆 Daqing	76.28	8.02	3.63	9.01	3.06
同江 Tongjiang	81.81	8.34	2.98	4.28	1.58
北安 Beian	57.80	3.22	13.80	21.34	3.84
讷河 Nehe	78.37	5.52	4.85	9.19	2.07

样点 Site	鞍型 Saddle	帽型 Rondel	尖型 Lanceolate	扇型 Bulliform	棒型 Elongated
丹东 Dandong	78.95	7.66	0.89	7.17	5.33
盘锦 Panjin	79.20	9.04	3.71	2.75	5.30
龙湾 Longwan	87.33	6.00	1.02	4.18	1.47
通辽 Tongliao	88.31	7.80	0.53	0.98	2.38
长春 Changchun	83.90	5.60	2.19	5.60	2.71
牡丹江 Mudanjiang	84.58	4.24	1.19	8.07	1.92
长岭 Changling	85.06	6.58	3.71	2.60	2.05
哈尔滨 Harbin	53.22	3.20	18.02	17.29	8.27
大庆 Daqing	76.28	8.02	3.63	9.01	3.06
同江 Tongjiang	81.81	8.34	2.98	4.28	1.58
北安 Beian	57.80	3.22	13.80	21.34	3.84
讷河 Nehe	78.37	5.52	4.85	9.19	2.07

样点 Site	6月 June	7月 July	8月 August	9月 September	10月 October
丹东 Dandong	91.91	94.68	77.75	60.25	72.05
盘锦 Panjin	81.97	76.57	85.20	77.13	64.33
龙湾 Longwan	-	86.24	84.01	90.42	83.28
通辽 Tongliao	-	88.48	84.55	93.17	87.82
长春 Changchun	91.77	89.59	81.74	80.30	60.57
牡丹江 Mudanjiang	87.23	90.84	85.23	75.83	82.57
长岭 Changling	83.76	98.93	88.96	-	73.19
哈尔滨 Harbin	66.26	75.69	64.16	29.73	29.70
大庆 Daqing	85.20	85.40	62.54	72.51	82.40
同江 Tongjiang	86.57	89.68	75.20	78.17	-
讷河 Nehe	70.06	82.57	81.17	-	-
北安 Beian	76.44	89.63	32.60	55.13	61.67