花生抗旱性鉴定指标的筛选与评价

doi:10.3724/SP.J.1258.2011.00100

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

为确定鉴定花生(Arachis hypogaea)品种(系)抗旱性指标体系, 综合评价花生品种(系)的抗旱性, 在人工控水条件下, 通过盆栽试验, 测定了29个花生品种(系)苗期和花针期的株高、分枝数、生物累积量、叶片含水量和光合色素含量等与抗旱性有关的13个表观形态性状和生理性状的指标, 采用抗旱系数法和隶属函数值法, 对各指标性状进行了水分胁迫下的抗性评价和鉴定。结果表明, 29个花生品种(系)可划分为抗旱性较强、中等、较弱和不抗旱4类, 其中‘唐科8号’、‘冀花2号’、‘大唐油’、‘花育25号’、‘花育17号’、‘鲁花14号’、‘丰花1号’ 7个品种(系)具有较强的抗旱能力; 苗期同一品种(系)的主茎高、分枝数和生物累积量等形态指标和光合色素等生理指标的隶属函数值均有较大差别, 苗期各指标隶属函数值与品种(系)抗旱性无显著相关关系, 苗期单一形态指标不能作为鉴定品种(系)抗旱性的指标; 但苗期抗旱性综合评价值(D)与抗旱系数间存在显著相关关系, D的大小可作为抗旱性的鉴定指标。花针期形态指标和生理指标D值间, 以及各类指标D值与抗旱系数间均存在显著或极显著的相关关系, 此期植株形态指标、生理指标隶属函数值以及综合D值均可作为鉴定品种(系)抗旱性的指标。

关键词: 花生, 综合评价, 抗旱性, 品种(系), 水分胁迫

Abstract:

Aims Our objective was to define an index of peanut (Arachis hypogaea) drought resistance and comprehensively evaluate drought resistance of peanut varieties under controlled water conditions.
Methods The experiment was conducted on the farm of Qingdao Academy of Agricultural Science with 29 peanut varieties. Two levels of water content (80%-85% and 45%-50% of field moisture capacity) were used in a randomized complete block design with four replications. We measured 13 morphological and physiological characters such as plant height, branch numbers, biomass, leaf water content and photosynthetic pigment content in seedling and pod-pin stages.
Important findings The 29 peanut cultivars can divided into four classes: high-, mid- and low-tolerant cultivars and intolerant cultivars. The high-tolerant cultivars included ‘Tangke 8’, ‘Jihua 2’, ‘Datangyou’, ‘Huayu 25’, ‘Huayu 17’, ‘Luhua 14’ and ‘Fenghua 1’. Subordinate function values of the morphological indexes including main stem height, branch number and biomass, and photosynthetic pigments contents of the same cultivars at seedling stage were different. In addition, the subordinate function value of the seedling stage was unrelated to drought resistance, so a single physiological index cannot be used to identify the drought resistance of peanut. But the values drought resistance comprehensive evaluation (D) of physiological indexes were significantly related to drought resistance and can be used to identify the drought resistance of peanut. At the pod-pin stage, the D values of morphological indexes and physiological indexes were both significantly related to drought resistance, so the subordinate function value and D value of morphological indexes and physiological indexes at this stage can serve as indexes for identifying peanut drought resistance.

Key words: Arachis hypogaea, comprehensive appraisal, drought resistance, varieties, water stress

张智猛, 万书波, 戴良香, 宋文武, 陈静, 石运庆. 花生抗旱性鉴定指标的筛选与评价. 植物生态学报, 2011, 35(1): 100-109. DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1258.2011.00100

ZHANG Zhi-Meng, WAN Shu-Bo, DAI Liang-Xiang, SONG Wen-Wu, CHEN Jing, SHI Yun-Qing. Estimating and screening of drought resistance indexes of peanut. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 2011, 35(1): 100-109. DOI: 10.3724/SP.J.1258.2011.00100

导出引用管理器 EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

链接本文: https://www.plant-ecology.com/CN/10.3724/SP.J.1258.2011.00100

https://www.plant-ecology.com/CN/Y2011/V35/I1/100

图/表 6

参考文献 21

[1]	Bai LP (白莉萍), Sui FG (隋方功), Sun CH (孙朝晖), Ge TD (葛体达), Lü YY (吕银燕), Zhou GS (周广胜) (2004). Effects of soil water stress on morphological development and yield of maize. Acta Agronomica Sinica (作物学报), 24, 1556-1569. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[2]	Cheng JF (程建峰), Pan XY (潘晓云), Liu YB (刘宜柏), Dai TB (戴廷波), Cao WX (曹卫星) (2005). Morphological indexes of drought resistance identification in rice. Acta Ecologica Sinica (生态学报), 25, 3117-3125. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[3]	Guan BH (关保华), Ge Y (葛滢), Fan MY (樊梅英), Niu XY (牛晓音), Lu YJ (卢毅军), Chang J (常杰) (2003). Phenotypic plasticity of growth and morphology in Mosla chinensis responds to diverse relative soil water content. Acta Ecologica Sinica (生态学报), 23, 259-263. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[4]	Hsiao TC (1973). Plant responses to water stress. Annual Review of Plant Physiology, 24, 519-570. DOI URL
[5]	Hu BL (胡标林), Yu SW (余守武), Wan Y (万勇), Zhang Z (张铮), Qiu BY (邱兵余), Xie JK (谢建坤) (2007). Drought-resistance identification of dongxiang common wild rice (Oryza rufipogon) in whole growth period. Acta Agronomica Sinica (作物学报), 33, 425-432. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[6]	Jiang HF (姜慧芳), Ren XP (任小平) (2004). The effect on SOD activity and protein content in groundnut leaves by drought stress. Acta Agronomica Sinica (作物学报), 30, 169-174. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[7]	Li GQ (李贵全), Li HF (李慧峰), Zhang HY (张海燕), Wu SJ (吴慎杰), Du WJ (杜维俊), Guo SJ (郭数进), Li L (李玲), Jiao BC (焦碧蝉) (2007). Comprehensive evaluation of flowering-podding period drought resistance of soybean. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture (中国生态农业学报), 15(6), 96-100. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[8]	Li Y (黎裕) (1993). The identification method and index for crop drought resistance . Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas (干旱地区农业研究), 10(1), 91-99. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[9]	Li YQ (栗雨琴), Zhang WY (张文英), Wang YZ (王有增), Li YC (李运朝), Liu GR (刘桂茹), Gu JT (谷俊涛), Zhou JB (周进宝) (2004). Advances of studies on crop drought resistance identification. Journal of Hebei Agricultural Sciences (河北农业科学), 8(1), 58-61. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[10]	Meng L (孟林), Mao PC (毛培春), Zhang GF (张国芳), Shi XX (史晓霞) (2008). Combination effects of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium on Pennisetum purpureum. Pratacultural Science (草业科学), 25(1), 21-25. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[11]	Shan L (山仑) (2002). Development trend of dryland farming technologies. Scientia Agricultura Sinica (中国农业科学), 35, 848-855. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[12]	Shan L (山仑), Zhang SQ (张岁岐) (1999). Water saving agriculture and its biological basis. Research of Soil and Water Conservation (水土保持研究), 6(1), 3-6. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[13]	Shanghai Society for Plant Physiology (上海市植物生理学会) (1999). Experimental Manual of Plant Physiology (植物生理学实验手册). Shanghai Science and Technology Press, Shanghai. 130-157. (in Chinese)
[14]	Shao RX (邵瑞鑫), Shangguan ZP (上官周平) (2008). Effects of exogenous nitric oxide donor sodium nitroprusside on photosynthetic pigment content and light use capability of PSII in wheat under water stress. Acta Agronomica Sinica (作物学报), 34, 818-822. (in Chinese with English abstract) DOI URL
[15]	Shao YJ (邵艳军), Shan L (山仑) (2006). Advances in the studies on drought tolerance mechanism of plants. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture (中国生态农业学报), 14(4), 16-20. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[16]	Wang HZ (王贺正) (2007). Study on Drought Resistance and Screening Identification Indexes of Drought Resistance in Rice (水稻抗旱性研究及其鉴定指标的筛选). PhD dissertation, Sichuan Agriculture University, Ya’an, Sichuan. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[17]	Wang HZ (王贺正), Ma J (马均), Li XY (李旭毅), Li Y (李艳), Zhang RP (张荣萍), Liu HY (刘慧远), Wang RQ (汪仁全) (2005). Screening identification indexes of drought resistance at flowering stage in rice. Acta Agronomica Sinica (作物学报), 31, 1485-1489. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[18]	Wang YH (王育红), Yao YQ (姚宇卿), Lü JJ (吕军杰), Li Y (李瑜), Liu HQ (刘红旗) (2002). A preliminary study on the indexes of peanut varieties. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas (干旱地区农业研究), 20(3), 89-92. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[19]	Yan ML (严美玲), Li XD (李向东), Lin YJ (林英杰), Wang LL (王丽丽), Zhou LY (周录英) (2007). Effects of drought during seedling stage on physiological traits, yield and quality of different peanut cultivars. Acta Agronomica Sinica (作物学报), 33, 113-119. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[20]	Ye NH (叶乃好), Zhai H (翟衡), Du ZJ (杜中军), Xu H (许宏) (2004). Evaluation of drought resistance of ten apple rootstock. Journal of Fruit Science (果树学报), 21, 395-398. (in Chinese with English abstract)
[21]	Zhang CJ (张灿军), Wang YH (王育红), Yao YQ (姚宇卿), Lü JJ (吕军杰), Wang CH (王聪慧), Zhang J (张洁), Li JH (李俊红) (2005). Study on drought-resistance identification methods and evaluation index of dry-land rice— Technical criterion for identification and evaluation of drought-resistance. Agricultural Research in the Arid Areas (干旱地区农业研究), 23(4), 37-39. (in Chinese with English abstract)

品种(系) Varieties (strains)	抗旱系数 Drought coefficient	隶属函数 Subordinate function						D值 D value
品种(系) Varieties (strains)	抗旱系数 Drought coefficient	主茎高 Length of main stem	分枝数 No. of banches	地上部鲜重 Shoot fresh weight	地上部干重 Shoot dry weight	叶片鲜重 Leaf fresh weight	叶片干重 Leaf dry weight	D值 D value
‘G2’	0.561^cd	0.211^d	0.500b^c	0.243^d	0.530^c	0.341^cd	0.675^b	0.564^bc
‘鲁花14号’ ‘Luhua 14’	0.766^bc	1.000a	0.500^bc	0.170^d	0.149^d	0.209^d	0.141^d	0.472^c
‘丰花1号’ ‘Fenghua 1’	0.863^bc	0.406^cd	0.500^bc	0.997a	0.569^bc	0.602^bc	0.705^b	0.501^c
‘冀花2号’ ‘Jihua 2’	0.980^bc	0.415^cd	0.500^bc	0.374^cd	0.502^cd	0.552^bc	0.662^bc	0.545^bc
‘冀花4号’ ‘Jihua 4’	1.256^ab	0.314^cd	0.500^bc	0.167^d	0.236^d	0.237^cd	0.311^cd	0.553^bc
‘丰花6号’ ‘Fenghua 6’	0.543^cd	0.434^cd	0.500^bc	0.425^cd	0.567^bc	0.625^bc	0.809^ab	0.553^bc
‘花育22号’ ‘Huayu 22’	1.542^a	0.256^d	0.500^bc	0.197^d	0.309^d	0.223^d	0.352^cd	0.550^bc
‘TE-2’	0.497^cd	0.705^bc	0.121^c	0.887^ab	1.002^a	0.864^ab	0.997^a	0.281e
‘大唐油’ ‘Datangyou’	0.880^bc	0.344^cd	0.500^bc	0.501^c	0.696^bc	0.714^b	0.896^ab	0.549^bc
‘阜花11号’ ‘Fuhua 11’	0.604^cd	0.474^cd	0.500^bc	0.239^d	0.374^cd	0.275^cd	0.365^cd	0.516^c
‘花育24号’ ‘Huayu 24’	1.070^b	0.862^ab	1.000^ab	0.403^cd	0.409^cd	0.468^c	0.408^c	0.695^ab
‘阜花10号’ ‘Fuhua 10’	0.706^c	0.305^cd	0.500^bc	0.233^d	0.335^cd	0.323^cd	0.442^c	0.555^bc
‘唐油4号’ ‘Tangyou 4’	0.990^bc	0.000^d	0.000^c	0.446^cd	0.619^bc	0.650^bc	0.802^ab	0.362^d
‘花育20号’ ‘Huayu 20’	1.229^ab	0.296^cd	0.500^bc	0.100^d	0.193^d	0.137^d	0.251^cd	0.555^bc
‘花育23号’ ‘Huayu 23’	0.328^d	0.186^d	0.500^bc	0.000^d	0.000^d	0.002^d	0.000^d	0.565^bc
‘花育25号’ ‘Huayu 25’	1.000^bc	0.426^cd	0.500^bc	0.607^bc	0.759^b	0.891^ab	0.924^ab	0.532^bc
‘花育21号’ ‘Huayu 21’	1.072^b	0.545^bc	0.500^bc	0.486^c	0.641^bc	0.654^bc	0.804^ab	0.524^bc
‘潍花8号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.780^bc	0.490^c	0.500^bc	0.433^cd	0.461^cd	0.578^bc	0.533^bc	0.521^c
‘鲁花11号’ ‘Luhua 11’	0.870^bc	0.273^cd	0.500^bc	0.263^d	0.307^d	0.364^cd	0.337^cd	0.546^bc
‘花育16号’ ‘Huayu 16’	0.450^cd	0.641^bc	0.500^bc	0.598^bc	0.795^ab	0.817^ab	0.967^a	0.508^c
‘花育19号’ ‘Huayu 19’	0.375^cd	0.542^bc	0.500^bc	0.284^cd	0.400^cd	0.366^cd	0.439^c	0.516^c
‘唐科8号’ ‘Tangke 8’	1.486^a	0.400^cd	0.500^bc	0.363^cd	0.456^cd	0.492^bc	0.583^bc	0.542^bc
‘阜花13号’ ‘Fuhua 13’	0.385^cd	0.034^d	0.500^bc	0.088^d	0.218^d	0.199^d	0.325^cd	0.592^b
‘花育17号’ ‘Huayu 17’	1.367^ab	0.572^bc	0.500^bc	0.429^cd	0.546^bc	0.609^bc	0.927^ab	0.562^bc
‘花育27号’ ‘Huayu 27’	1.040^b	0.450^cd	0.500^bc	0.306^cd	0.398^cd	0.440^cd	0.487^bc	0.534^bc
‘潍花6号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.854^bc	0.418^cd	0.500^bc	0.346^cd	0.556^bc	0.539^bc	0.800^ab	0.558^bc
‘M5’	0.689^c	0.762^b	0.500^bc	0.748^b	0.864^ab	1.000^a	0.889^ab	0.466^c
‘16-8’	0.845^bc	0.822^ab	0.500^bc	0.436^cd	0.560^bc	0.526^bc	0.656^bc	0.486^c
‘M7’	0.322^d	0.418^cd	0.500^bc	0.289^cd	0.382^cd	0.378^cd	0.440^c	0.532^bc

品种(系) Varieties (strains)	抗旱系数 Drought coefficient	隶属函数 Subordinate function						D值 D value
品种(系) Varieties (strains)	抗旱系数 Drought coefficient	主茎高 Length of main stem	分枝数 No. of banches	地上部鲜重 Shoot fresh weight	地上部干重 Shoot dry weight	叶片鲜重 Leaf fresh weight	叶片干重 Leaf dry weight	D值 D value
‘G2’	0.561^cd	0.211^d	0.500b^c	0.243^d	0.530^c	0.341^cd	0.675^b	0.564^bc
‘鲁花14号’ ‘Luhua 14’	0.766^bc	1.000a	0.500^bc	0.170^d	0.149^d	0.209^d	0.141^d	0.472^c
‘丰花1号’ ‘Fenghua 1’	0.863^bc	0.406^cd	0.500^bc	0.997a	0.569^bc	0.602^bc	0.705^b	0.501^c
‘冀花2号’ ‘Jihua 2’	0.980^bc	0.415^cd	0.500^bc	0.374^cd	0.502^cd	0.552^bc	0.662^bc	0.545^bc
‘冀花4号’ ‘Jihua 4’	1.256^ab	0.314^cd	0.500^bc	0.167^d	0.236^d	0.237^cd	0.311^cd	0.553^bc
‘丰花6号’ ‘Fenghua 6’	0.543^cd	0.434^cd	0.500^bc	0.425^cd	0.567^bc	0.625^bc	0.809^ab	0.553^bc
‘花育22号’ ‘Huayu 22’	1.542^a	0.256^d	0.500^bc	0.197^d	0.309^d	0.223^d	0.352^cd	0.550^bc
‘TE-2’	0.497^cd	0.705^bc	0.121^c	0.887^ab	1.002^a	0.864^ab	0.997^a	0.281e
‘大唐油’ ‘Datangyou’	0.880^bc	0.344^cd	0.500^bc	0.501^c	0.696^bc	0.714^b	0.896^ab	0.549^bc
‘阜花11号’ ‘Fuhua 11’	0.604^cd	0.474^cd	0.500^bc	0.239^d	0.374^cd	0.275^cd	0.365^cd	0.516^c
‘花育24号’ ‘Huayu 24’	1.070^b	0.862^ab	1.000^ab	0.403^cd	0.409^cd	0.468^c	0.408^c	0.695^ab
‘阜花10号’ ‘Fuhua 10’	0.706^c	0.305^cd	0.500^bc	0.233^d	0.335^cd	0.323^cd	0.442^c	0.555^bc
‘唐油4号’ ‘Tangyou 4’	0.990^bc	0.000^d	0.000^c	0.446^cd	0.619^bc	0.650^bc	0.802^ab	0.362^d
‘花育20号’ ‘Huayu 20’	1.229^ab	0.296^cd	0.500^bc	0.100^d	0.193^d	0.137^d	0.251^cd	0.555^bc
‘花育23号’ ‘Huayu 23’	0.328^d	0.186^d	0.500^bc	0.000^d	0.000^d	0.002^d	0.000^d	0.565^bc
‘花育25号’ ‘Huayu 25’	1.000^bc	0.426^cd	0.500^bc	0.607^bc	0.759^b	0.891^ab	0.924^ab	0.532^bc
‘花育21号’ ‘Huayu 21’	1.072^b	0.545^bc	0.500^bc	0.486^c	0.641^bc	0.654^bc	0.804^ab	0.524^bc
‘潍花8号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.780^bc	0.490^c	0.500^bc	0.433^cd	0.461^cd	0.578^bc	0.533^bc	0.521^c
‘鲁花11号’ ‘Luhua 11’	0.870^bc	0.273^cd	0.500^bc	0.263^d	0.307^d	0.364^cd	0.337^cd	0.546^bc
‘花育16号’ ‘Huayu 16’	0.450^cd	0.641^bc	0.500^bc	0.598^bc	0.795^ab	0.817^ab	0.967^a	0.508^c
‘花育19号’ ‘Huayu 19’	0.375^cd	0.542^bc	0.500^bc	0.284^cd	0.400^cd	0.366^cd	0.439^c	0.516^c
‘唐科8号’ ‘Tangke 8’	1.486^a	0.400^cd	0.500^bc	0.363^cd	0.456^cd	0.492^bc	0.583^bc	0.542^bc
‘阜花13号’ ‘Fuhua 13’	0.385^cd	0.034^d	0.500^bc	0.088^d	0.218^d	0.199^d	0.325^cd	0.592^b
‘花育17号’ ‘Huayu 17’	1.367^ab	0.572^bc	0.500^bc	0.429^cd	0.546^bc	0.609^bc	0.927^ab	0.562^bc
‘花育27号’ ‘Huayu 27’	1.040^b	0.450^cd	0.500^bc	0.306^cd	0.398^cd	0.440^cd	0.487^bc	0.534^bc
‘潍花6号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.854^bc	0.418^cd	0.500^bc	0.346^cd	0.556^bc	0.539^bc	0.800^ab	0.558^bc
‘M5’	0.689^c	0.762^b	0.500^bc	0.748^b	0.864^ab	1.000^a	0.889^ab	0.466^c
‘16-8’	0.845^bc	0.822^ab	0.500^bc	0.436^cd	0.560^bc	0.526^bc	0.656^bc	0.486^c
‘M7’	0.322^d	0.418^cd	0.500^bc	0.289^cd	0.382^cd	0.378^cd	0.440^c	0.532^bc

品种(系) Varieties (strains)	比叶面积 Specific leaf area	Chl a	Chl b	Chl a + b	类胡萝卜素 Carotenoid	叶片含水量 Leaf water content	地上部含水量 Shoot water content	D值 D value
‘G2’	0.746^b	0.705^bc	0.549^bc	0.890^ab	0.000^d	0.000^e	0.000^d	0.598^b
‘鲁花14号’ ‘Luhua 14’	0.685^bc	0.103^d	0.096^d	0.085^cd	0.966^ab	1.000^a	0.360^b	0.585^bc
‘丰花1号’ ‘Fenghua 1’	0.758^b	0.011^d	0.036^d	0.017^d	0.763^b	0.575^c	1.000^ab	0.664^ab
‘冀花2号’ ‘Jihua 2’	1.000^a	0.447^c	0.565^bc	0.468^bc	0.474^c	0.558^cd	0.279^bc	0.702^a
‘冀花4号’ ‘Jihua 4’	0.679^bc	0.267^cd	0.328^cd	0.269^cd	0.742^bc	0.555^cd	0.279^bc	0.598^b
‘丰花6号’ ‘Fenghua 6’	0.508^cd	0.344^cd	0.386^c	0.345^cd	0.514^c	0.461^cd	0.223^bc	0.494^c
‘花育22号’ ‘Huayu 22’	0.551^c	0.751^ab	0.672^b	0.828^ab	0.520^c	0.405^cd	0.178^c	0.552^bc
‘TE-2’	0.460^cd	0.157^d	0.159^cd	0.145^cd	0.644^bc	0.646^bc	0.294^bc	0.471^cd
‘大唐油’ ‘Datangyou’	0.341^d	0.311^cd	0.649^b	0.429^bc	0.357^c	0.481^cd	0.200^c	0.362^de
‘阜花11号’ ‘Fuhua 11’	0.620^bc	0.143^d	0.186^cd	0.115^cd	0.358^c	0.526^cd	0.173^c	0.504^bc
‘花育24号’ ‘Huayu 24’	0.485^cd	1.000^a	0.543^bc	1.000^a	0.669^bc	0.824^ab	0.328^bc	0.531^bc
‘阜花10号’ ‘Fuhua 10’	0.382^cd	0.574^bc	0.808^ab	0.645^b	0.531^c	0.484^cd	0.211^bc	0.423^cd
‘唐油4号’ ‘Tangyou 4’	0.449^cd	0.193^cd	0.076^d	0.121^cd	0.926^ab	0.514^cd	0.207^bc	0.537^bc
‘花育20号’ ‘Huayu 20’	0.520^cd	0.507^bc	0.702^b	0.564^bc	0.018^d	0.410^cd	0.180^c	0.412^cd
‘花育23号’ ‘Huayu 23’	0.441^cd	0.534^bc	0.859^ab	0.636^bc	0.409^c	0.747^bc	0.278^bc	0.390^d
‘花育25号’ ‘Huayu 25’	0.580^bc	0.393^cd	0.509^bc	0.425^bc	0.548^bc	0.687^bc	0.251^bc	0.499^c
‘花育21号’ ‘Huayu 21’	0.409^cd	0.120^d	0.081^d	0.095^cd	0.853^ab	0.517^cd	0.229^bc	0.499^c
‘潍花8号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.470^cd	0.419^c	0.325^cd	0.362^bc	0.873^ab	0.790^b	0.316^bc	0.508^bc
‘鲁花11号’ ‘Luhua 11’	0.429^cd	0.190^cd	0.214^cd	0.058^cd	0.528^c	0.824^ab	0.282^bc	0.409^cd
‘花育16号’ ‘Huayu 16’	0.254^d	0.047^d	0.000^d	0.000^d	1.000^a	0.469^cd	0.221^bc	0.457^cd
‘花育19号’ ‘Huayu 19’	0.485^cd	0.706^b	1.000^a	0.804^ab	0.375^c	0.586^c	0.213^bc	0.429^cd
‘唐科8号’ ‘Tangke 8’	0.371^cd	0.200^cd	0.204^cd	0.186^cd	0.688^bc	0.577^c	0.253^bc	0.445^cd
‘阜花13号’ ‘Fuhua 13’	0.000^e	0.639^bc	0.534^bc	0.779^ab	0.401^c	0.432^cd	0.127^cd	0.270^e
‘花育17号’ ‘Huayu 17’	0.824^ab	0.500^bc	0.592^bc	0.518^bc	0.638^bc	0.308^de	0.121^cd	0.677^ab
‘花育27号’ ‘Huayu 27’	0.527^cd	0.122^d	0.060^d	0.083^cd	0.840^ab	0.637^bc	0.266^bc	0.540^bc
‘潍花6号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.461^cd	0.000^d	0.200^cd	0.192^cd	0.566^bc	0.370^de	0.160^cd	0.473^cd
‘M5’	0.476^cd	0.000^d	0.129^cd	0.058^cd	0.585^bc	0.869^ab	0.292^bc	0.426^cd
‘16-8’	0.282^d	0.071^d	0.129^cd	0.038^d	0.528^c	0.518^cd	0.240^bc	0.376^d
‘M7’	0.423^cd	0.253^cd	0.214^cd	0.216^cd	0.721^bc	0.611^bc	0.235^bc	0.474^cd

品种(系) Varieties (strains)	比叶面积 Specific leaf area	Chl a	Chl b	Chl a + b	类胡萝卜素 Carotenoid	叶片含水量 Leaf water content	地上部含水量 Shoot water content	D值 D value
‘G2’	0.746^b	0.705^bc	0.549^bc	0.890^ab	0.000^d	0.000^e	0.000^d	0.598^b
‘鲁花14号’ ‘Luhua 14’	0.685^bc	0.103^d	0.096^d	0.085^cd	0.966^ab	1.000^a	0.360^b	0.585^bc
‘丰花1号’ ‘Fenghua 1’	0.758^b	0.011^d	0.036^d	0.017^d	0.763^b	0.575^c	1.000^ab	0.664^ab
‘冀花2号’ ‘Jihua 2’	1.000^a	0.447^c	0.565^bc	0.468^bc	0.474^c	0.558^cd	0.279^bc	0.702^a
‘冀花4号’ ‘Jihua 4’	0.679^bc	0.267^cd	0.328^cd	0.269^cd	0.742^bc	0.555^cd	0.279^bc	0.598^b
‘丰花6号’ ‘Fenghua 6’	0.508^cd	0.344^cd	0.386^c	0.345^cd	0.514^c	0.461^cd	0.223^bc	0.494^c
‘花育22号’ ‘Huayu 22’	0.551^c	0.751^ab	0.672^b	0.828^ab	0.520^c	0.405^cd	0.178^c	0.552^bc
‘TE-2’	0.460^cd	0.157^d	0.159^cd	0.145^cd	0.644^bc	0.646^bc	0.294^bc	0.471^cd
‘大唐油’ ‘Datangyou’	0.341^d	0.311^cd	0.649^b	0.429^bc	0.357^c	0.481^cd	0.200^c	0.362^de
‘阜花11号’ ‘Fuhua 11’	0.620^bc	0.143^d	0.186^cd	0.115^cd	0.358^c	0.526^cd	0.173^c	0.504^bc
‘花育24号’ ‘Huayu 24’	0.485^cd	1.000^a	0.543^bc	1.000^a	0.669^bc	0.824^ab	0.328^bc	0.531^bc
‘阜花10号’ ‘Fuhua 10’	0.382^cd	0.574^bc	0.808^ab	0.645^b	0.531^c	0.484^cd	0.211^bc	0.423^cd
‘唐油4号’ ‘Tangyou 4’	0.449^cd	0.193^cd	0.076^d	0.121^cd	0.926^ab	0.514^cd	0.207^bc	0.537^bc
‘花育20号’ ‘Huayu 20’	0.520^cd	0.507^bc	0.702^b	0.564^bc	0.018^d	0.410^cd	0.180^c	0.412^cd
‘花育23号’ ‘Huayu 23’	0.441^cd	0.534^bc	0.859^ab	0.636^bc	0.409^c	0.747^bc	0.278^bc	0.390^d
‘花育25号’ ‘Huayu 25’	0.580^bc	0.393^cd	0.509^bc	0.425^bc	0.548^bc	0.687^bc	0.251^bc	0.499^c
‘花育21号’ ‘Huayu 21’	0.409^cd	0.120^d	0.081^d	0.095^cd	0.853^ab	0.517^cd	0.229^bc	0.499^c
‘潍花8号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.470^cd	0.419^c	0.325^cd	0.362^bc	0.873^ab	0.790^b	0.316^bc	0.508^bc
‘鲁花11号’ ‘Luhua 11’	0.429^cd	0.190^cd	0.214^cd	0.058^cd	0.528^c	0.824^ab	0.282^bc	0.409^cd
‘花育16号’ ‘Huayu 16’	0.254^d	0.047^d	0.000^d	0.000^d	1.000^a	0.469^cd	0.221^bc	0.457^cd
‘花育19号’ ‘Huayu 19’	0.485^cd	0.706^b	1.000^a	0.804^ab	0.375^c	0.586^c	0.213^bc	0.429^cd
‘唐科8号’ ‘Tangke 8’	0.371^cd	0.200^cd	0.204^cd	0.186^cd	0.688^bc	0.577^c	0.253^bc	0.445^cd
‘阜花13号’ ‘Fuhua 13’	0.000^e	0.639^bc	0.534^bc	0.779^ab	0.401^c	0.432^cd	0.127^cd	0.270^e
‘花育17号’ ‘Huayu 17’	0.824^ab	0.500^bc	0.592^bc	0.518^bc	0.638^bc	0.308^de	0.121^cd	0.677^ab
‘花育27号’ ‘Huayu 27’	0.527^cd	0.122^d	0.060^d	0.083^cd	0.840^ab	0.637^bc	0.266^bc	0.540^bc
‘潍花6号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.461^cd	0.000^d	0.200^cd	0.192^cd	0.566^bc	0.370^de	0.160^cd	0.473^cd
‘M5’	0.476^cd	0.000^d	0.129^cd	0.058^cd	0.585^bc	0.869^ab	0.292^bc	0.426^cd
‘16-8’	0.282^d	0.071^d	0.129^cd	0.038^d	0.528^c	0.518^cd	0.240^bc	0.376^d
‘M7’	0.423^cd	0.253^cd	0.214^cd	0.216^cd	0.721^bc	0.611^bc	0.235^bc	0.474^cd

品种(系) Varieties (strains)	主茎高 Length of main stem	分枝数 No. of branches	地上部鲜重 Shoot fresh weight	地上部干重 Shoot dry weight	叶片鲜重 Leaf fresh weight	叶片干重 Leaf dry weight	D值 D value
‘G2’	0.262 ^cd	0.524^bc	0.322^c	0.371^bc	0.131^cd	0.576^b	0.359^c
‘鲁花14号’ ‘Luhua 14’	0.229^d	1.000^a	0.637^b	0.342^bc	0.324^bc	0.574^b	0.519^bc
‘丰花1号’ ‘Fenghua 1’	0.458^c	0.263^cd	1.000^a	0.459^b	0.518^b	0.825^ab	0.579^b
‘冀花2号’ ‘Jihua 2’	0.422^cd	0.502^bc	0.342^c	0.216^c	0.145^cd	0.893^ab	0.410^bc
‘冀花4号’ ‘Jihua 4’	0.402^cd	0.402^bc	0.272^c	0.006^d	0.090^d	0.982^a	0.347^c
‘丰花6号’ ‘Fenghua 6’	0.052^de	0.152^cd	0.084^cd	0.004^d	0.054^d	0.012^c	0.061^d
‘花育22号’ ‘Huayu 22’	0.442^cd	0.632^b	0.885^ab	0.488^b	0.413^bc	0.791^ab	0.603^ab
‘TE-2’	0.577^bc	0.167^cd	0.517^bc	0.214^c	0.205^cd	0.500^bc	0.359^c
‘大唐油’ ‘Datangyou’	0.284^cd	0.405^bc	0.463^bc	0.347^bc	0.277^cd	0.842^ab	0.426^bc
‘阜花11号’ ‘Fuhua 11’	0.137^de	0.405^bc	0.290^c	0.148^cd	0.161^cd	0.351^bc	0.247^cd
‘花育24号’ ‘Huayu 24’	0.461^c	0.286^cd	0.658^b	0.404^bc	0.263^cd	0.538^bc	0.430^bc
‘阜花10号’ ‘Fuhua 10’	0.122^de	0.524^bc	0.433^bc	0.201^cd	0.229^cd	0.403^bc	0.318^cd
‘唐油4号’ ‘Tangyou 4’	0.450^cd	0.425^bc	0.887^ab	0.403^bc	0.475^b	0.827^ab	0.571^b
‘花育20号’ ‘Huayu 20’	0.184^de	0.439^bc	0.196^cd	0.201^cd	0.098^d	0.425^bc	0.254^cd
‘花育23号’ ‘Huayu 23’	0.281^cd	0.000^d	0.422^bc	0.408^bc	0.185^cd	0.850^ab	0.342^c
‘花育25号’ ‘Huayu 25’	0.584^bc	0.375^c	0.633^b	0.348^bc	0.295^c	0.629^b	0.472^bc
‘花育21号’ ‘Huayu 21’	0.509^bc	0.881^a	0.796^ab	0.514^b	0.372^bc	0.857^ab	0.650^ab
‘潍花8号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.211^de	0.524^bc	0.471^bc	0.223^c	0.220^cd	0.224^c	0.315^cd
‘鲁花11号’ ‘Luhua 11’	0.533^bc	0.127^d	0.475^bc	0.203^cd	0.175^cd	0.232^c	0.290^cd
‘花育16号’ ‘Huayu 16’	0.207^de	0.226^cd	0.201^cd	0.043^cd	0.056^d	0.052^c	0.133^d
‘花育19号’ ‘Huayu 19’	0.313^cd	0.167^cd	0.603^bc	0.407^bc	0.329^bc	0.875^ab	0.436^bc
‘唐科8号’ ‘Tangke 8’	0.498^bc	0.762^ab	0.756^ab	1.000^a	1.000^a	0.625^b	0.776^a
‘阜花13号’ ‘Fuhua 13’	0.000^e	0.416^bc	0.133^cd	0.047^cd	0.041^d	0.002^c	0.110^d
‘花育17号’ ‘Huayu 17’	1.000^a	0.881^a	0.804^ab	0.464^b	0.417^bc	0.857^ab	0.735^ab
‘花育27号’ ‘Huayu 27’	0.801^ab	0.524^bc	0.908^ab	0.375^bc	0.460^b	1.000^a	0.670^ab
‘潍花6号’ ‘Weihua 8’	0.699^b	0.405^bc	0.743^ab	0.183^cd	0.349^bc	0.353^bc	0.458^bc
‘M5’	0.386^cd	0.141^cd	0.498^bc	0.080^cd	0.213^cd	0.004^c	0.225^cd
‘16-8’	0.607^bc	0.524^bc	0.815^ab	0.453^b	0.383^bc	0.731^ab	0.580^b
‘M7’	0.098^de	0.262^cd	0.000^d	0.059^cd	0.007^d	0.156^c	0.095^d